• thynne-macartney-logo
  • Expertise
  • People
  • About Us
  • News & Insights
  • Careers
  • Contact Us
  • Dye & Durham Refund
  • Pay Invoice

Shattered: Sorghum growers’ claim rejected by Supreme Court

14 July 2021

In April this year, the Supreme Court in Mallonland Pty Ltd & Anor v Advanta Seeds Pty Ltd [2021] QSC 74 rejected a claim by a group of sorghum growers for damages said to have been suffered from seed which included the shattercane weed.

Shattercane is genetically related to sorghum but produces a seed pod that cannot be harvested. On maturity, the seed pod “shatters”, spreading thousands of seeds of the invasive plant which can significantly affect field yields for many years.

Damages claimed by the growers were in the order of $104 million.

The Court found that the seed bags contained a disclaimer of responsibility which excluded any duty of care that the seed manufacturer may have owed the growers to prevent economic loss from weed infection. The disclaimer read as follows:

CONDITIONS OF SALE AND USE

Upon purchasing this product and opening the bag, the purchaser (“you”) agrees to be bound by the conditions set out below…

    • You acknowledge that… it remains your responsibility to satisfy yourself that the product in the bag is fit for its intended use…
    • Pacific Seeds Pty Ltd will not be liable to you… for any injury, loss or damage caused or contributed to by Pacific Seeds Pty Ltd (or its servants or agents), directly or indirectly arising out of or related to the use of the product in this bag, whether as a result of their negligence or otherwise…

This meant the negligence claim failed.

The growers also claimed damages for “misleading or deceptive conduct” by the seed manufacturer for remaining silent while aware of the shattercane infestation. However, the Judge found that the seed manufacturer did not know of the infestation at the relevant time.

Thynne + Macartney can assist growers to review their supply agreements and adopt strategies to minimise similar risks.

 

field-of-sorghum

 

Author: Nick Knowlman (Lawyer)

News & Insights

Best Lawyers Australia recognises Michael Fisher, Matthew Hockaday and Alex Ramsey as Lawyers of the Year

Best Lawyers Australia recognises Michael Fisher, Matthew Hockaday and Alex Ramsey as Lawyers of the Year

Read More
Nuclear spring causes fission in Callide

Nuclear spring causes fission in Callide

Read More
Mining lease objections review

Mining lease objections review

Read More
Biosecurity management plans: free pass for resource companies

Biosecurity management plans: free pass for resource companies

Read More

Stay updated

Get the latest news straight to your inbox

Subscribe to receive the latest updates from us!

Pick the area or areas of law that interest you.

Subscribe

Contact Us

  • 07 3231 8888
  • 07 3229 0855
  • mail@thymac.com.au
      • linkedin-logo

 

Liability limited by a scheme approved
under professional standards legislation.

Brisbane Office
  • Level 32, Riverside Centre
    123 Eagle Street
    BRISBANE QLD 4000
Cairns Office
  • Level 1, Moresby Haus
    4 Scott Street
    CAIRNS QLD 4870

  • 07 3231 8888
  • 07 3229 0855
  • mail@thymac.com.au
      • linkedin-logo

 

Liability limited by a scheme approved
under professional standards legislation.

  • © Thynne + Macartney 2025
    • Disclaimer
    • Privacy Policy